• Contact
main menu
    back
      img

      EU Parliament SFDR 2.0 New Draft | Key Changes Explained

      ESG Insights
      img

      Shai Hill

      CEO & Founder

      Shai began his career on the buyside at what is now JP Morgan AM, before moving to the sellside where he worked in several research roles. He was Head of Research at Macquarie Group for 10 years before founding Integrum ESG in 2018. Shai has an M.A. from Cambridge University.

      The EU Parliament has published its draft negotiating position on the Commission's proposed SFDR 2.0 reforms, proposing stricter requirements for ESG-labelled funds in several areas and extending mandatory PAI disclosures to product level across all three categories.

      The European Commission published its proposed updates to SFDR 2.0 earlier this year, setting out a new three-category product framework to replace the existing Article 8 and Article 9 structure. That proposal now moves into trilogue negotiations and the EU Parliament has set out where it agrees, where it diverges and what changes it will push for.

      The Parliament's draft position retains the overall architecture of the Commission's proposal but introduces material changes in several areas. For asset managers currently using broad ESG integration to maintain a categorised label, the proposed requirements are more demanding than those in the Commission's baseline.

      This article summarises the key differences between the Commission's baseline proposal and the Parliament's draft, and explains what the changes could mean for funds currently classified as Article 8.

      Short on time? Speak to our team about where your funds land under SFDR 2.0. 


       

      Key Takeaways 

      • The Parliament retains the Commission's three-category framework but proposes stricter requirements for the ESG Basics category.
      • Benchmark alignment alone will not be sufficient to satisfy category requirements under the Parliament's draft.
      • Mandatory PAI disclosures at product level are proposed across all three categories, directly contrary to the Commission's efforts to reduce PAI burden.
      • Most current Article 8 funds planning to rely on the ESG Basics label face more demanding analysis and disclosure requirements if the Parliament's position prevails.
      • Negotiations are at an early stage - the final text will emerge from trilogue between the Parliament, the Commission and the Council.

         

       

      What does the new draft change?

      Across six areas, the Parliament's draft either tightens the Commission's requirements or introduces new obligations that the Commission had not proposed.

      Overall architecture

      The Parliament's draft explicitly preserves the three-category system and minimum criteria framework put forward by the Commission.

      There is no structural renegotiation of the overall approach. This signals broad political agreement on the direction of reform, and limits the scope for fundamental reversals in trilogue.

      Where the Parliament diverges is in the detail of what each category requires, and in the obligations that apply across all three.

      ESG Basics category (Article 8)

      The Commission proposed a broad ESG integration category with limited quantitative requirements. The Parliament's draft tightens this considerably.

      Under the Parliament's position, funds seeking to carry the ESG Basics label must remove at least 20 percent of their worst-performing investments by sustainability rating or value before they can demonstrate ESG characteristics.

      This is a higher bar than the Commission envisaged and requires a more deliberate and evidenced exclusion process at the portfolio level.

      For funds currently classified as Article 8, this is the most direct change in the draft.

      CTB and PAB benchmarks

      The Commission's proposal allowed funds tracking a Climate Transition Benchmark or Paris-Aligned Benchmark to use that alignment as a form of safe harbour, simplifying the path to category compliance.

      The Parliament has removed this provision. Under the draft, benchmark tracking alone does not satisfy the requirements for any of the three categories.

      Funds will need to demonstrate compliance on the basis of their own portfolio construction and methodology, independently of their benchmark.

      PAI indicators

      The Commission sought to reduce the overall PAI burden, particularly at entity level, through fewer indicators and simplified disclosure requirements.

      The Parliament is moving in the opposite direction at product level.

      The draft introduces mandatory PAI disclosures across all three categories. A core set of PAIs, to be specified in Level 2 legislation, would apply to all products. In addition, funds would be required to report on further PAIs where they are material to the product strategy.

      This represents a material increase in disclosure obligations for funds that currently sit within a categorised label while avoiding PAI reporting.

      Engagement disclosure

      The Commission placed limited emphasis on engagement in its proposal.

      The Parliament's draft strengthens this, requiring all three categories to disclose their engagement policies and the outcomes of engagement activity on a comply-or-explain basis.

      This creates a disclosure obligation even for funds that do not engage actively, who would need to explain the absence of a policy.

      Non-categorised products

      Funds that do not fall into any of the three ESG categories would be required to carry an explicit disclaimer stating that the product does not meet EU sustainability category standards.

      The Commission's approach permitted references to ESG factors with restrictions on claims.

      The Parliament's draft mandates a direct negative statement rather than simply restricting positive ones.
       


       

      Summary of Key Differences

      AreaCommission proposalParliament draft
      Overall architectureThree voluntary categories (Transition, ESG Basics and Sustainable) with 70% portfolio threshold and restrictions on ESG claimsRetained without structural change
      ESG Basics categoryBroad ESG integration with limited quantitative testRequires removal of at least 20% of worst-performing holdings before demonstrating ESG characteristics
      CTB / PAB benchmarksBenchmark alignment can provide safe harbourSafe harbour removed. Benchmark tracking alone is not sufficient to meet category requirements
      PAI indicators (core structure)Reduced burden, fewer indicators, simplified disclosuresMandatory product-level PAI disclosures across all categories plus additional material indicators
      PAI indicators (scope and flexibility)Streamlined, reduced obligation at entity levelMandatory core set of PAIs for all products specified in Level 2, plus additional PAIs where material to product strategy
      Engagement disclosureLess central in Commission proposalDisclosure of engagement policies and outcomes required on a comply-or-explain basis across all categories
      Non-categorised productsMay reference ESG factors with restrictions on claimsMust carry an explicit disclaimer stating the product does not meet EU sustainability category standards


       



      For more on how Climate Transition Benchmarks and Paris-Aligned Benchmarks interact with the new SFDR framework, see our article CTB and PAB Exclusions Explained.


       

      What does this mean for current Article 8 funds?

      A large number of current Article 8 funds are expected to seek reclassification into the ESG Basics category under the new framework.

      Many of these funds currently use a provision in the existing SFDR rules that allows them to avoid reporting on any Principal Adverse Impacts.

      If the Parliament's position carries into the final text, those funds would face:

      • an active exclusion requirement, removing at least 20 percent of worst-performing holdings before demonstrating ESG characteristics
      • mandatory PAI disclosures at product level for a core set of indicators defined in Level 2 legislation
      • the removal of any benchmark safe harbour that might have simplified compliance
      • a comply-or-explain obligation on engagement policies and outcomes

      The path from Article 8 to ESG Basics is more demanding under the Parliament's draft than under the Commission's proposal. Funds that had assumed a straightforward reclassification may need to revisit that position.
       



      For a full breakdown of SFDR 2.0 requirements and how they apply to your funds, Integrum ESG's SFDR Intelligence solution gives asset managers a current, verified view of obligations across the new categories.


       

      What does this mean for asset managers more broadly?

      Even for managers who are not directly affected by the ESG Basics changes, the Parliament's draft indicates a broader shift in the direction of product-level disclosure requirements. Across most of the contested areas, the Parliament's position proposes more disclosure and more evidence rather than less.

      Two themes are particularly relevant for planning purposes.

      First, the removal of the benchmark safe harbour means that classification decisions will need to stand on their own merits. A fund cannot rely on its index selection as a proxy for sustainability compliance.

      Second, the extension of mandatory PAI obligations to product level across all categories increases the data and reporting infrastructure required to maintain a categorised label.

      Managers with limited ESG data coverage or early-stage PAI reporting processes will need to assess the gap against what the Parliament's draft would require.


       

      Where does the process go from here?

      The Parliament's draft is a starting point for its negotiating position, not a final view. The Council of the EU will also develop its own position, and trilogue negotiations between all three institutions will determine the final text.

      Full implementation remains expected from 2028, with technical standards to be developed through 2026 and 2027. The Commission's proposal is the current baseline, and the Parliament's draft does not change any immediate regulatory obligations.

      The Parliament's draft does, however, indicate that stricter product-level requirements are likely to be part of the trilogue discussion. Asset managers should monitor developments and avoid treating the Commission's proposal as a settled outcome.


      For a full overview of the Commission's original SFDR 2.0 proposals, see our earlier article: SFDR 2.0 Explained: What Asset Managers Must Do Next 


       

      What should asset managers do now?

      The Parliament's draft does not change the immediate regulatory requirements. However, managers planning for the transition should revisit any assumptions made on the basis of the Commission's proposal alone.
      In particular:

      • funds that assumed a straightforward migration to ESG Basics should assess whether they could meet the exclusion threshold under the Parliament's draft
      • managers who had factored in benchmark alignment as a compliance route should plan for a scenario in which that route is unavailable
      • PAI data readiness should be assessed now, given the Parliament's intent to extend product-level PAI obligations across all categories
      • engagement frameworks and documentation should be reviewed against the comply-or-explain standard proposed in the draft

       

      How Integrum ESG supports SFDR 2.0 Preparation

      The Parliament's draft gives asset managers enough to act on now.

      Funds mapping a path from Article 8 to ESG Basics need to revisit that assumption, and the PAI data requirements implied by the draft go well beyond what most currently produce.

      Identifying where your funds sit under the new categories is the logical first step. Integrum ESG can run that assessment for you, across fund classification, PAI data coverage and exclusion policy gaps.

      Speak to an Integrum ESG Expert today.

      Unlock black boxes and see inside your future investments.

      img

      More, straight to your inbox.

      Your investment decisions have never been clearer.

      Say goodbye to black boxes — and hello to our proprietary glass-box data.
      shape

      Questions? We’re an open book.

      Browse frequently asked questions about the platform.

      The EU Parliament has published a draft negotiating position setting out the amendments it will seek during trilogue negotiations on the Commission's proposed SFDR 2.0 reforms. The draft retains the three-category framework of Transition, ESG Basics and Sustainable funds but proposes stricter requirements for the ESG Basics category, removes the benchmark safe harbour and introduces mandatory PAI disclosures at product level across all three categories.

      The Commission's proposal introduced a broad ESG integration category with limited quantitative requirements and sought to reduce the overall PAI burden. The Parliament's draft tightens the ESG Basics category by requiring removal of at least 20 percent of worst-performing holdings before a fund can demonstrate ESG characteristics, removes benchmark alignment as a safe harbour and proposes mandatory product-level PAI disclosures for all categorised funds.

      Under the current SFDR framework, many Article 8 funds use a provision that allows them to avoid reporting on Principal Adverse Impacts. A large number of these funds are expected to seek reclassification as ESG Basics under SFDR 2.0. If the Parliament's position is adopted in the final text, those funds would need to meet an active exclusion requirement, report on a mandatory core set of PAIs and demonstrate compliance independently of any benchmark alignment.

      Trilogue is the interinstitutional negotiation process between the European Parliament, the European Commission and the Council of the EU. Each institution develops its own position and the three then negotiate a final agreed text. The Parliament's draft negotiating position is its starting point for that process. The final SFDR 2.0 text will reflect the outcome of those negotiations.

      Full implementation of SFDR 2.0 is expected from 2028. Technical standards are being developed through 2026 and 2027. A transition period is expected in 2027 and 2028. The Parliament's draft does not change any immediate regulatory obligations under the current SFDR framework.

      Still have questions?

      Can’t find the answer you’re looking for? Please get in touch with our team.

      Speak to an Experticon