• Contact
main menu
    back
      img

      Untangling Financed Emissions

      · Updated ESG Insights
      img

      Molly Frazer

      Senior Research Analyst

      Molly joined the Research Team at Integrum ESG in 2021, having previously worked as a Research Analyst at the A.I powered B2B services company Globality. Molly has a BSc in Economics from the University of Bristol, an MSc in Economics and Policy of Energy & the Environment at UCL and she holds the CFA UK Level 4 Certificate in ESG Investing.

      For financial institutions, financed emissions - the emissions associated with the companies they invest in or lend to - are a key measure of climate impact.

      However, accurately measuring and reporting them remains a challenge.

      What Are Financed Emissions?

      Under the GHG Protocol, financed emissions fall under Category 15 (Investments) of Scope 3 emissions, covering the emissions linked to loans, investments and other financial services.

      The Partnership for Carbon Accounting Financials (PCAF), which builds off the GHG protocol, provides guidance for financial institutions to disclose Scope 1 & 2 emissions of their portfolio companies.

      However, if a portfolio company operates in a sector where Scope 3 emissions are deemed material (e.g. Oil & Gas), then its Scope 3 emissions must also be included.

      Measuring financed emissions will vary depending on the type of financial service provided.

      How should financed emissions be scaled?

      One challenge is determining the appropriate scaling factor for financed emissions, to ensure effective benchmarking. 

      We looked at 10 publicly listed asset managers' disclosed absolute financed emissions. To benchmark them we first scale by revenue - but acknowledging that the asset management fee structure can significantly impact this, despite similar levels of invested capital, we also scale by AUM. 

      As you can see from the tables below, the results vary considerably:

      Table 1 - asset managers with the highest disclosed financed emissions

      Company

      Country

      Absolute Financed Emissions (tCO₂e)

      Northern Trust Corp

      United States

      411232377

      M&G

      United Kingdom

      122315000

      Janus Henderson Group

      United Kingdom

      77984516

      Ameriprise Financial

      United States

      18000000

      Azimut Holding S.p.A

      Italy

      12495050

      Nomura Holdings

      Japan

      7480000

      Apollo Asset Management

      United States

      7450808

      IGM Financial

      Canada

      6400000

      Polar Capital

      United Kingdom

      5261232

      Eurazeo

      France

      3549051

       

      Table 2 - asset managers with the highest disclosed financed emissions, scaled by revenue

      Company

      Country

      Financed Emissions (tCO₂e/USDm revenue)

      Northern Trust Corp

      United States

      60711.95

      Janus Henderson Group

      United Kingdom

      37103.68

      Polar Capital

      United Kingdom

      20871.53

      M&G

      United Kingdom

      9223.12

      Azimut Holding S.p.A

      Italy

      8311.3

      Eurazeo

      France

      8103.81

      IGM Financial

      Canada

      2332.73

      Ameriprise Financial

      United States

      1158.67

      Nomura Holdings

      Japan

      822.49

      Apollo Asset Management

      United States

      228.24

       

      Table 3 - asset managers with the highest disclosed financed emissions, scaled by AUM

      Company

      Country

      Financed Emissions (tCO₂e/USDm revenue)

      Northern Trust Corp

      United States

      373.85

      Janus Henderson Group

      United Kingdom

      225.56

      Azimut Holding S.p.A

      Italy

      189.23

      Polar Capital

      United Kingdom

      185.09

      M&G

      United Kingdom

      122.81

      Eurazeo

      France

      92.97

      IGM Financial

      Canada

      26.66

      Ameriprise Financial

      United States

      26.43

      Nomura Holdings

      Japan

      12.58

      Apollo Asset Management

      United States

      11.45

       

      Is the scaled AUM table a fairer comparison? It can be, depending on the methodology. 

      AUM is arguably a better benchmark than revenue as it directly reflects exposure to investments and emissions tied to its portfolio, while revenue can be impacted by external factors or fee structures. However, scaling by revenue allows for wider comparisons, not only between AMs but also with the financials sector as a whole.

      Is the data comparable at this stage?

      Another existing challenge is data comparability.

      Many public companies do not disclose their full emissions in line with recognised standards, e.g. the GHG protocol, particularly when it comes to Scope 3 data.

      This then becomes a challenge for banks that are required to report their financed Scope 3 emissions, as public company disclosures of Scope 3 data remain inconsistent or incomplete.

      This raises a key question: Is it fair to expect financial institutions to disclose their portfolio’s Scope 3 emissions when they ultimately rely on the underlying company reported data?

      What is Integrum’s approach?

      At Integrum ESG, as we’ve been collecting financed emissions data for financial institutions, we have debated what the right approach is.

      Should we accept a bank’s reported financed emissions if they have only disclosed Scope 1 & 2 for their portfolio companies?

      Or should we be strict and only include companies that provide full Scope 1, 2, and 3 figures in line with PCAF guidance, even if that significantly reduces the dataset?

      Ultimately, we decided that best practice for financial institutions is to clearly define what their Scope 3 Category 15 financed emissions value includes.

      We believe financial institutions should clearly define their approach, specifying:

      🏦 The % of their AUM covered

      🏭 Which scopes (1, 2, and/or 3) have been included and why

      🧮 If they have used third-party estimates to fill in disclosure gaps

      Conclusion

      As long as a financial institution is transparent about its methodology, adheres to a recognised standard, and provides a justified explanation for any exclusions (such as the omission of Scope 3 emissions) then we believe its reported value can be considered reliable.


      Unlock black boxes and see inside your future investments.

      img

      More, straight to your inbox.

      Your investment decisions have never been clearer.

      Say goodbye to black boxes — and hello to our proprietary glass-box data.
      shape