• Contact
main menu
    back
      img

      New York City Comptroller calls for divestment from BlackRock, Fidelity & PanAgora

      · Updated ESG Insights
      img

      Abbie Main

      Head of Business Development

      Abbie joined Integrum ESG as Head of Business Development in 2025. Prior to this, Abbie headed up the Sales Team at SeedLegals, consistently driving double digit YoY growth. Having worked in a variety of Sales roles in multiple industries (Digital Marketing, Law, Fashion, LegalTech), Abbie has a keen awareness of understanding exactly what a prospective client needs, in order to translate this into a successful product and commercial strategy. Abbie has a M.A. in Modern Languages from Oxford University.

      New York City Comptroller Brad Lander has recommended that three of the city’s pension funds re-evaluate mandates currently managed by BlackRock, Fidelity Investments and PanAgora.

      The recommendation focuses on concerns related to climate planning, escalation and voting alignment. If adopted, the decision could affect up to $42.3 billion in assets.


       

      Key takeaways

      • NYC Comptroller proposes cutting mandates with BlackRock, Fidelity and PanAgora over climate and stewardship concerns
      • The review focuses on decarbonisation planning, escalation activity and alignment between stated policies and voting outcomes
      • The mandates under review span managers of different sizes, from the world’s largest asset manager to mid-sized active firms
      • BlackRock has issued a detailed response, while Fidelity and PanAgora have not commented publicly
         

       

      What happened?

      On 26 November 2025, NYC Comptroller Brad Lander released an update to the city’s Net Zero Implementation Plan recommending that three pension funds re-bid or terminate mandates with BlackRock, Fidelity and PanAgora.

      Lander argued that all three firms fell short of the systems’ expectations on climate alignment. His statement said that “46 out of 49 public markets managers” met the required decarbonisation criteria but BlackRock, Fidelity and PanAgora did not.

      He also criticised BlackRock’s decision to restrict certain stewardship activities in the United States, describing this as an “abdication of financial duty”.

      The mandates under review represent a significant spread of manager types:

      • BlackRock manages more than $10 trillion globally and is a core provider of index and active strategies to US pension systems
      • Fidelity Investments manages approximately $4.5 trillion across mutual funds, retirement platforms and institutional mandates
      • PanAgora Asset Management is a mid-sized quantitative manager with roughly $30 billion in assets under management

      This variation underscores that climate stewardship expectations are being applied across the market, from the largest index providers to smaller active managers.

      BlackRock issued a public response stating that the recommendation “politicises public pension funds and undermines the retirement security of hardworking New Yorkers” and emphasised that it provides a broad range of client-directed approaches.
      Source: BlackRock statement, 26 November 2025

      Fidelity Investments and PanAgora have not released public statements to date.

      The pension boards will review the recommendation, and any reallocation decision will rest with the trustees. 


       

      Why this matters for investors

      The NYC review highlights how climate and stewardship factors are increasingly assessed alongside traditional performance criteria in mandate evaluations.

      Three themes are notable:

      1. Asset owners are examining evidence rather than statements

      The review focused on decarbonisation plans, escalation activity, voting records and consistency between firm level policies and fund level delivery.

      These are practical indicators of how managers approach climate risk.

      2. Climate alignment is becoming part of routine mandate oversight

      The NYC review fits within a broader trend in which asset owners periodically assess stewardship delivery as part of investment discipline.

      This is not limited to specialist ESG mandates but applies across standard equity strategies. These case studies show that mandate decisions now integrate emissions reporting, transition planning and stewardship quality into standard due diligence for managers of all sizes.

      3. Climate and stewardship expectations now apply across manager sizes

      Large reallocations in recent years have involved major global managers, but this case shows similar expectations being applied to mid-sized firms such as PanAgora. 

      This broadens the relevance of climate alignment beyond a small set of headline names.


       

      Recommendations for asset managers

      The NYC review reinforces that asset owners assess climate and stewardship delivery through observable evidence, not high level commitments. In mandate renewals and searches, managers that can demonstrate:

      • Clear decarbonisation plans
      • Consistent voting aligned with stated policies
      • Documented escalation with companies
      • Transparent reporting on outcomes
      • Credible data supporting their climate approach

      are better positioned to meet evolving expectations.

      Across both large global firms and mid-sized managers, cases such as this highlight that asset owners value sustained, verifiable implementation of climate and stewardship frameworks. 

      Managers that can evidence this through data and practice, rather than principle alone, are more resilient in competitive evaluations.


       

      Protect your mandates with credible ESG & Climate intelligence

      As pension funds strengthen their climate and stewardship expectations, advantage is shifting toward managers that can pair strong investment capability with transparent data, robust engagement evidence and clear decarbonisation planning. 

      The NYC review shows that these factors are now assessed across managers of all sizes, from large index providers to mid-sized active firms. 

      Managers that can demonstrate consistent, data backed delivery on climate and stewardship expectations are better positioned to retain and win institutional mandates.

      Unlock black boxes and see inside your future investments.

      img

      More, straight to your inbox.

      Your investment decisions have never been clearer.

      Say goodbye to black boxes — and hello to our proprietary glass-box data.
      shape

      Questions? We’re an open book.

      Browse frequently asked questions about the platform.

      NYC Comptroller Brad Lander recommended that three city pension funds re-evaluate mandates with BlackRock, Fidelity and PanAgora on the grounds that all three fell short of the systems' expectations on climate alignment. The review focused on decarbonisation planning, escalation activity and alignment between stated stewardship policies and actual voting outcomes. Lander noted that 46 out of 49 public markets managers met the required criteria but these three did not.

      The mandates under review represent up to $42.3 billion in assets spanning three of the city's pension funds. The variation in manager size, from BlackRock as the world's largest asset manager to mid-sized quantitative firm PanAgora, underscores that climate stewardship expectations are being applied across the full spectrum of manager types.

      The review assessed decarbonisation plans, consistency between firm-level stewardship policies and fund-level voting outcomes, escalation activity with companies and the quality of climate reporting and evidence. These are practical indicators of how managers approach climate risk rather than high level commitments or principle statements.

      The NYC review reinforces that asset owners are examining evidence rather than statements when assessing climate and stewardship delivery. Climate alignment is becoming part of routine mandate oversight across both specialist ESG mandates and standard equity strategies, and the case shows that expectations apply to managers of all sizes, not just the largest index providers. Managers that can demonstrate consistent, data-backed delivery on climate and stewardship are better positioned to retain and win institutional mandates.

      Asset managers should ensure they have clear and documented decarbonisation plans, voting records that are consistent with stated policies, evidence of escalation activity with companies and transparent climate reporting supported by verifiable data. In mandate renewals and competitive searches, the ability to demonstrate credible implementation through observable evidence is increasingly a differentiating factor.

      Still have questions?

      Can’t find the answer you’re looking for? Please get in touch with our team.

      Speak to an Experticon